An Analysis of Students’ Mathematical Reasoning in Solving Indefinite Integral Problems Based on Lithner’s Framework
Main Article Content
Abstract
Correct solutions to indefinite integral problems can result from applying routine procedures and therefore provide limited evidence of the reasoning students used. Drawing on Lithner’s framework, this study examined the types and components of mathematical reasoning evident in students’ written solutions and explored how errors related to reasoning type. A descriptive–interpretive qualitative document analysis was conducted on 20 scanned handwritten scripts, comprising 19 scripts covering 13 odd-numbered antiderivative items and one definite-integral script used for comparison. Qualitative content analysis involved deductive coding of strategy choice, implementation, argumentation, and mathematical foundation, followed by classification into four levels (A–D) according to the dominant reasoning pattern and categorization of errors. All 19 antiderivative scripts exhibited algorithmic reasoning. Eleven showed procedural steps alone, five stated a general rule, and three provided reasons or specified conditions for a rule’s validity. No script met all three criteria for creative reasoning or showed verification by differentiation. Errors were associated with the reuse of procedural templates across items, copying slips, and uncritical interpretations of notation. The findings show that the routine tasks examined elicited imitative reasoning and underscore that creative reasoning requires strategic novelty alongside mathematical grounding. The study provides coding indicators and reasoning levels for analyzing written solutions and identifies ways to design calculus assessments that require students to verify results, justify strategies, and test the conditions under which rules apply. The analysis was limited to written evidence and relied on a single coder.
Citation Metrics:
Downloads
Citation Metrics & Similar Scopus Articles
-
Boyjanov N.I. (2027)Mathematical analysis of the linear increase in SiO2 content during the activation of Navbakhor alkaline bentonite with hydrochloric acidKompleksnoe Ispolzovanie Mineralnogo Syra, 342(3), 90-99
-
Kazhikenova S.S. (2028)Modelling and Solving Problems of Sustainable Efficiency of Technological Processes in MetallurgyKompleksnoe Ispolzovanie Mineralnogo Syra, 344(1), 65-78
-
Kurambayev S.R. (2028)Mathematical modeling and ecological assessment of fluoride release in a mixture of mineralized phosphorite waste and wastewater from the fat and oil industryKompleksnoe Ispolzovanie Mineralnogo Syra, 345(2), 95-106
Article Details

Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
References
Altindis, N. (2025). Networking theories of quantitative reasoning and mathematical reasoning to explore students’ understanding of functions. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 80, Article 101276.
Baroody, A. J., Feil, Y., & Johnson, A. R. (2007). An alternative reconceptualization of procedural and conceptual knowledge. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 38(2), 115–131.
Bergqvist, E. (2007). Types of reasoning required in university exams in mathematics. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 26, 348–370.
Bergqvist, T., & Lithner, J. (2012). Mathematical reasoning in teachers’ presentations. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 31(2), 252–269.
Bergqvist, T., Lithner, J., & Sumpter, L. (2008). Upper secondary students’ task reasoning. International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 39(1), 1–12.
Boesen, J., Lithner, J., & Palm, T. (2010). The relation between types of assessment tasks and the mathematical reasoning students use. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 75(1), 89–105. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10649-010-9242-9
Callingham, R., & Siemon, D. (2021). Connecting multiplicative thinking and mathematical reasoning in the middle years. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 61, Article 100837.
Carlson, M., Jacobs, S., Coe, E., Larsen, S., & Hsu, E. (2002). Applying covariational reasoning while modeling dynamic events: A framework and a study. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 33(5), 352–378.
Engelbrecht, J., Harding, A., & Potgieter, M. (2005). Undergraduate students’ performance and confidence in procedural and conceptual mathematics. International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 36(7), 701–712.
Jäder, J., Lithner, J., & Sidenvall, J. (2020). Mathematical problem solving in textbooks from twelve countries. International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 51(7), 1120–1136.
Jäder, J., Sidenvall, J., & Sumpter, L. (2017). Students’ mathematical reasoning and beliefs in non-routine task solving. International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 15(4), 759–776. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10763-016-9712-3
Jeannotte, D., & Kieran, C. (2017). A conceptual model of mathematical reasoning for school mathematics. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 96(1), 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10649-017-9761-8
Jones, S. R. (2013). Understanding the integral: Students’ symbolic forms. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 32(2), 122–141.
Jones, S. R. (2015a). Areas, anti-derivatives, and adding up pieces: Definite integrals in pure mathematics and applied science contexts. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 38, 9–28.
Jones, S. R. (2015b). The prevalence of area-under-a-curve and anti-derivative conceptions over Riemann sum-based conceptions in students’ explanations of definite integrals. International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 46(5), 721–736.
Jonsson, B., Granberg, C., & Lithner, J. (2020). Gaining mathematical understanding: The effects of creative mathematical reasoning and cognitive proficiency. Frontiers in Psychology, 11, Article 574366. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.574366
Jonsson, B., Norqvist, M., Liljekvist, Y., & Lithner, J. (2014). Learning mathematics through algorithmic and creative reasoning. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 36, 20–32.
Lithner, J. (2000). Mathematical reasoning in school tasks. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 41(2), 165–190. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A:1003956417456
Lithner, J. (2003). Students’ mathematical reasoning in university textbook exercises. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 52(1), 29–55. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A:1023683716659
Lithner, J. (2004). Mathematical reasoning in calculus textbook exercises. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 23(4), 405–427.
Lithner, J. (2008). A research framework for creative and imitative reasoning. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 67(3), 255–276. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10649-007-9104-2
Lithner, J. (2011). University mathematics students’ learning difficulties. Education Inquiry, 2(2), 289–303.
Lithner, J. (2017). Principles for designing mathematical tasks that enhance imitative and creative reasoning. ZDM Mathematics Education, 49(6), 937–949. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11858-017-0867-3
Mac an Bhaird, C., Nolan, B. C., O’Shea, A., & Pfeiffer, K. (2017). A study of creative reasoning opportunities in assessments in undergraduate calculus courses. Research in Mathematics Education, 19(2), 147–162.
Mahir, N. (2009). Conceptual and procedural performance of undergraduate students in integration. International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 40(2), 201–211.
Mata-Pereira, J., & da Ponte, J.-P. (2017). Enhancing students’ mathematical reasoning in the classroom: Teacher actions facilitating generalization and justification. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 96(2), 169–186. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10649-017-9773-4
Norqvist, M., Jonsson, B., Lithner, J., Qwillbard, T., & Holm, L. (2019). Investigating algorithmic and creative reasoning strategies by eye tracking. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 55, Article 100701.
Orton, A. (1983). Students’ understanding of integration. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 14(1), 1–18. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF00704699
Sealey, V. (2014). A framework for characterizing student understanding of Riemann sums and definite integrals. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 33, 230–245.
Sholihah, U., & Asyhar, B. (2023). The students’ visual reasoning in solving integral problems. Journal Focus Action of Research Mathematic (Factor M), 6(2), 15–26. https://jurnalfaktarbiyah.iainkediri.ac.id/index.php/factorm/article/view/1988
Sidenvall, J., Lithner, J., & Jäder, J. (2015). Students’ reasoning in mathematics textbook task-solving. International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 46(4), 533–552.
Tallman, M. A., Carlson, M. P., Bressoud, D. M., & Pearson, M. (2016). A characterization of Calculus I final exams in U.S. colleges and universities. International Journal of Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education, 2(1), 105–133. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40753-015-0023-9
Tatira, B. (2025). Undergraduate students’ understanding of the application of integral calculus in kinematics. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 21(3), Article em2601. https://doi.org/10.29333/ejmste/16049


